Saturday, January 1, 2011

Why property is a good investment tool?

Why is property a good investment tool?  In order to answer this question, I am making the following assumptions for the model:

Cost/Valuation$1,000,000
Sell$1,200,000
Profit$200,000 20.00%
Interest Rate1.00%
Years30
Rental$3,000 3.6%


Let's now look at some calculations showing why property investment is a good investment tool and why many Singaporeans are hooked onto chasing this property bubble.  The above assumption is based on you buying a property for $1m and reselling it for $1.2m.  This looks like you can earn a cool $200k profit in a rising market.  However astute investors may ask what is the big deal of 20% profit?  Question is, is it really just a 20% profit?  Let's delve further... 


10%20%30%40%50%
Downpayment$100,000 $200,000 $300,000 $400,000 $500,000
Loan Amount$900,000 $800,000 $700,000 $600,000 $500,000
Stamp Duty$24,600 $24,600 $24,600 $24,600 $24,600
Total Initial Outlay$124,600 $224,600 $324,600 $424,600 $524,600
Interest Cost (1yr)$9,000 $8,000 $7,000 $6,000 $5,000
PMT$2,894.76 $2,573.12 $2,251.48 $1,929.84 $1,608.20
Total Outlay$124,600 $224,600 $324,600 $424,600 $524,600
Profit$202,400 $203,400 $204,400 $205,400 $206,400
Rate of Return162.44%90.56%62.97%48.37%39.34%


Looking at the chart above (which assumes that the property is sold after 1 year), the rate of return depends greatly on the downpayment....bringing us to the greatest part of property investment.... LEVERAGE.

If you can leverage on a 90% loan, the profit is a cool 162%.  Of course, when you leverage less, the rate of return drops correspondingly.  However, do note that I am using 1% interest rate which to me is relatively low in the long run.  For flippers (which I am not), the interest rate is not really a concern as they will be selling in the short term, i.e. little impact due to the short term of loan.  However, when interest goes up, it will be a lot harder to sell the property.  Here's why....

10%20%30%40%50%
Downpayment$100,000 $200,000 $300,000 $400,000 $500,000
Loan Amount$900,000 $800,000 $700,000 $600,000 $500,000
Stamp Duty$24,600 $24,600 $24,600 $24,600 $24,600
Total Initial Outlay$124,600 $224,600 $324,600 $424,600 $524,600
Interest Cost (1yr)$36,000 $32,000 $28,000 $24,000 $20,000
PMT$4,296.74 $3,819.32 $3,341.91 $2,864.49 $2,387.08
Total Outlay$124,600 $224,600 $324,600 $424,600 $524,600
Profit$175,400 $179,400 $183,400 $187,400 $191,400
Rate of Return140.77%79.88%56.50%44.14%36.48%


The above is based on 4% interest rate which is very possible in the mid term.  As you can see, the rate of return drops by as much as 22% for 90% leverage but it is still relatively attractive (as the flipper sells within 1 year).  However, it is no longer as attractive to buy the property.  At 1%, the monthly payment is $2895, meaning that if he can loan out at $3k, the property is self-financing.  However at 4%, it is now $4297, i.e. the new owner will have to cough up at least $1300 more.  At 8%, this figure goes up to a whopping $6604, way beyond what most investors can afford or are willing to pay.

No comments:

Post a Comment